SCHOOL | LOCATION | DIVISION |
| University of Detroit Mercy | Detroit, MI | Division I |
| Illinois Wesleyan University | Bloomington, IL | Division III |
| Capital University | Bexley, OH | Division III |
| Mount St. Joseph University | Delhi Township, OH | Division III |
| Edgewood College | Madison, WI | Division III |
| Wilmington College | Wilmington, OH | Division II |
| University of the Cumberlands | Williamsburg, KY | NAIA |
| Lake Erie College | Painesville, OH | Division II |
| DePauw University | Greencastle, IN | Division III |
| Heidelberg University | Tiffin, OH | Division III |
| University of Northwestern- St. Paul | St. Paul, MN | Division III |
| Otterbein University | Westerville, OH | Division III |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | Delaware, OH | Division III |
| Wittenberg University | Springfield, OH | Division III |
| Notre Dame College | South Euclid, OH | Division II |
| Spalding University | Louisville, KY | Division III |
| Ferrum College | Ferrum, VA | Division III |
| Madonna University | Livonia, MI | NAIA |
| Ohio Northern University | Ada, OH | Division III |
| Siena Heights University | Adrian, MI | Division II |
| Thomas More University | Crestview Hills, KY | NAIA |
| Indiana Tech University | Fort Wayne, IN | NAIA |
| Augustana College- Illinois | Rock Island, IL | Division III |
| Transylvania University | Lexington, KY | Division III |
| Oberlin College | Oberlin, OH | Division III |
| Carthage College | Kenosha, WI | Division III |
| Muskingum University | New Concord, OH | Division III |