SCHOOL | LOCATION | DIVISION |
| Lewis University | Romeoville, IL | Division II |
| Florida Southern College | Lakeland, FL | Division II |
| Kennesaw State University | Kennesaw, GA | Division I |
| College of Wooster | Wooster, OH | Division III |
| Earlham College | Richmond, IN | Division III |
| Mount St. Joseph University | Cincinnati, OH | Division III |
| Adrian College | Adrian, MI | Division III |
| Illinois Wesleyan University | Bloomington, IL | Division III |
| Lake Erie College | Painesville, OH | Division II |
| DePauw University | Greencastle, IN | Division III |
| Muskingum University | New Concord, OH | Division III |
| Heidelberg University | Tiffin, OH | Division III |
| University of Northwestern- St. Paul | St. Paul, MN | Division III |
| Otterbein University | Westerville, OH | Division III |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | Delaware, OH | Division III |
| Wittenberg University | Springfield, OH | Division III |
| Walsh University | North Canton, OH | Division II |
| Notre Dame College | South Euclid, OH | Division II |
| Young Harris College | Young Harris, GA | Division II |
| Baldwin Wallace University | Berea, OH | Division III |
| Allegheny College | Meadville, PA | Division III |
| University of Health Sciences and Pharmacy in St. Louis | St. Louis, MO | NAIA |
| Asbury University | Wilmore, KY | NAIA |
| University of Wisconsin- River Falls | River Falls, WI | Division III |
| Spalding University | Louisville, KY | Division III |
| Lourdes University | Sylvania, MI | NAIA |
| Missouri Western State University | St. Joseph, MO | Division II |
| Kenyon College | Gambier, OH | Division III |
| Beloit College | Beloit, WI | Division III |
| University of Findlay | Findlay, OH | Division II |
| Quincy University | Quincy, IL | Division II |
| Ferrum College | Ferrum, VA | Division III |
| Marietta College | Marietta, OH | Division III |
| Centre College | Danville, KY | Division III |
| Madonna University | Livonia, MI | NAIA |
| Randolph College | Lynchburg, VA | Division III |
| Virginia Wesleyan University | Virginia Beach, VA | Division III |
| Transylvania University | Lexington, KY | Division III |
| Capital University | Columbus, OH | Division III |
| Missouri Valley College | Marshall, MO | NAIA |
| Washington & Jefferson College | Washington, PA | Division III |
| Ashland University | Ashland, OH | Division II |
| Ursuline College | Pepper Pike, OH | Division II |
| Indiana Tech University | Fort Wayne, IN | NAIA |